Archive
Archive for January 15, 2010
Comments on Freemuth’s piece in HCN
Some of these comments sounded worthy of discussion. I was intrigued by the concept that somehow collaboration avoids NEPA and other legal requirements. I guess I was having trouble imagining collaborating at any level on anything that ultimately results in decisions that violate legal requirements- because the legal nexus is the decision. Can someone help me understand this concern further?
Categories: collaboration and public involvement
Benedict’s Corner
When the conduct of men is designed to be influenced, persuasion, kind, unassuming persuasion, should ever be adopted. It is an old and a true maxim, that a "drop of honey catches more flies than a gallon of gall." —
Abraham Lincoln
Recommended Comment Considerations
When commenting, please consider the three doors that charitable speech must pass through.
The gatekeeper at the door asks, "Is it true?" The second gatekeeper asks, "Is it helpful?" The third gatekeeper asks, "Is it kind?"
(adapted from the writings of Krishnamurti by James Martin on p. 169 of this book.)
Recent Posts
- Dialogue in an Era of Divisiveness: ACR 2013 Conference
- Wisconsin wildfire started by logging operations destroys 17 homes
- Kissing the Past Gently Good-bye
- Buffalo Nightmare: 3 Days of Taxpayer-Funded Yellowstone Helicopter Hazing
- How Feminism Wrecked the US Forest Service
- US boom transforming global oil trade
- Colorado: Green Industries With Wood
- Court Upholds Forest Plan for Black Hills
- Lawsuit filed against Kootenai National Forest logging project
- Oregon Laws Proposed to Punish Logging Protesters
Contacts
Questions? Complaints? Kudos? Contact Sharon at terraveritas atgmaildotcom.
Purpose
We intend to provide a forum where different academic communities (social, physical and biological disciplines, law, policy), agency employees and retirees, students and the general public can come together to share perspectives on national forest management and planning.
Disclaimer
The opinions expressed by those providing comments are theirs alone, and do not reflect the opinions of the any of their organizations.
Top Views
Archives
Science Policy Quote of the Month
"In the real world, many risks we face present neither the great certainties we would need to use cost-benefit analysis effectively nor the almost complete uncertainties that would justify radical precautionary approaches. Moreover, neither the precautionary principle nor cost-benefit analysis tell us anything about the role of democracy in making policy decisions.
I am currently working to develop new approaches rooted in deliberative democracy which might move beyond both strict cost-benefit and knee-jerk precaution toward processes that could achieve better public participation and greater political legitimacy on the major environmental threats to our future."
Jonathan Gilligan, Professor of Earth and Environmental Sciences on his website here.
On Learning Through Blogging
"From my perspective, I declare winning by participants (myself and others) asking questions, providing arguments, further developing an argument in response to other arguments, learning something, and possibly changing your mind about something. Its about the dialogue, I’m not interested in takedowns. "
Found here by Judith Curry at Georgia Tech
Tags
2012 Montana Wildfires
Alliance for Wild Rockies
Ash Creek Complex Fire
bark beetles
biomass
Biscuit Fire
Canada Lynx
Categorical exclusion
Center for Bioligical Diversity
center for biological diversity
climate change
Colt Summit Timber Sale
critical habitat
Ecological Value of Dead Trees
economics
Endangered Species Act
Fire and Fuels
Fourmile Canyon Fire
Idaho National Forests
Lewis and Clark National Forest
Lodgepole pine
Manomet Center for Conservation Sciences
Montana
montana timber industry
Montana wolf trapping
Natural Gas Drilling
old growth
OSHA Worker Safety
Photos
Public Lands Grazing Fees
Restoration
Senator Jon Tester
Sportsmen's heritage act
Stimulus Funds
Tongass National Forest
Tree Diseases and Insects
Tricon Timber
U.S. Fish and Wildlife Services
Wilderness Act
wildfire
wildfires
Wildlife
Wolerines
wolves
wood burning biomass plants
Blogroll
Forest Service Miscellany
References
Science Policy
Species Diversity/Viability
The West
Post Categories
- 2012 Planning Rule
- 21st Century Problems
- Access
- Accountability
- adaptive management
- Advice for Administration
- Agency Efficiencies
- Alaska Issues
- All Lands
- Appeals and Objections
- Bark Beetles
- Best available science
- Biomass
- Blog -Workin' It
- Budget
- Building Trust
- Business of Land Management
- Certification
- climate change
- collaboration and public involvement
- Communication
- Community Forest Management
- conflict resolution
- Congress
- Cool Technologies
- CREATE
- District of the Week
- Diversity and species conservation
- Economics and Economic Recovery
- Ecosystem Services
- Energy
- Environmental Organizations
- ESA
- Fire and Fuels
- Forest Products
- Forest Service: Culture, History, Morale, Organization, Future
- Future (Imagining our Mutual)
- GE Trees
- Good Things
- Grasslands
- Grazing
- History
- Humans and the Environment
- Interior West
- Invasives
- Jobs
- Lands
- Landscape Scale
- Law Enforcement
- Law Review
- Litigation
- Meetings of Interest
- Monitoring
- National Reserve Conservation Assocation
- Natural Resources
- Naturalist Interest
- NEPA
- Objections
- Old Growth
- Partizanizing Issues
- People's Database
- Photos
- Place-Based Bills & Agreements
- Planning
- Planning Rule Development Process
- Politics
- Press
- Privatization
- Projects of Interest
- Proposed Rule
- Recreation
- Reform and Enhance Litigation and Appeals
- Renewable energy- wind and solar
- Research
- Responses to NOI
- Restoration
- Roadless
- Role of local and state governments
- Role of science
- Sacred Sites
- Science Process Redesign
- Science- The Business of
- special forest products
- State and Federal Forests
- Stewardship
- Sustainable Rural Economies
- timber
- Travel Management
- Tree diseases and insects
- Trust Managaement
- Uncategorized
- Water
- What Should Plans Do?
- Wilderness
- Wood
- workforce
Recent Comments